House in Finger Lakes, NY
16 guests · 6 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this house rental
Summary:
This house is located in Penn Yan but your 24/7 support is always nearby.
This house features 6 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms with space enough for 16.
Please review our property photos and our available amenities to make sure this rental is a perfect fit for your needs. We strive to keep this information as up-to-date as possible so you can feel confident in knowing what you are renting.
The Space:
We will send you all necessary pre-arrival and check-in information after booking. This can include guest instructions, notices, and other helpful information.
What We Love
A restful pastoral retreat from the city, the Benton Farmhouse is the perfect place for large families and friend groups to reconnect and reflect with the people who mean the most to you. Spacious, and boasting old-world charm, this beautifully restored historic home radiates an abundance of warmth. Conveniently located on Route 14A in the middle of the Wine region of the Finger Lakes, this home is perfectly located to tour and explore the area. It can also serve as a relaxing base for wedding parties using multiple local wedding venues.
Enjoy cozy movie viewings from the comfort of the spacious living room's soft seating. Engage in some playful competition over a game of chess under the glow of the library's lamps, or any of the many games for all ages in the living room or the huge recreation room. When hunger arises, head for the well-equipped kitchen and play chef amongst the full suite of appliances and ample meal prep space. Serving your dishes will be a breeze at the expansive, formal dining table. After eating, enjoy a night in while playing Ping-Pong in the wood-lined recreation room/TV-watching area. Mix your game nights with delicious concoctions prepared at the recreation room bar.
With six large bedrooms to choose from, rest assured that no one's comfort will go unattended to. Each of the rooms offers soft linens, vintage decor pieces and furniture, and cool air - thanks to the home's partial air-conditioning. Additional interior perks include a private washer/dryer, a high chair, internet access, and office space with a desk and printer in the quiet library. After a couple of front door steps, the lower level of the house has a bathroom and bed available.
Outside, enjoy the country breeze while grilling or sitting in front of the dancing flames in the fire pit. Enormous lawns encourage spirited games of corn hole and badminton, while the large driveway can be set up for pickleball, all of which are supplied.
When exploring the surrounding area, be sure to check out the numerous regional wineries, excellent local restaurants (we can suggest our favorites), charming Penn Yan (“Penn' for the Pennsylvanians and “Yan” for the Yankees who settled the area in the early 1800s), the scenic Finger Lakes, Keuka Lake Outlet trail, Keuka Lake State Park, Finger Lakes Rail Riders (just around the corner), Canandaigua Country Club, or further up the road, Hunt Hollow Ski Club. Don't be surprised if you encounter horse-drawn buggies sharing local roads on your way to Windmill Market just south of Penn Yan, which hosts dozens of shops, produce, and food to enjoy.
House Rules
Check-in time: 4:00 PM
Check-out time: 10:00 AM
All guests shall abide by the good neighbor policy and shall not engage in illegal activity. Quiet hours are from 10:00 PM to 8:00 AM
No smoking is permitted anywhere on the premises.
This house is located in Penn Yan but your 24/7 support is always nearby.
This house features 6 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms with space enough for 16.
Please review our property photos and our available amenities to make sure this rental is a perfect fit for your needs. We strive to keep this information as up-to-date as possible so you can feel confident in knowing what you are renting.
The Space:
We will send you all necessary pre-arrival and check-in information after booking. This can include guest instructions, notices, and other helpful information.
What We Love
A restful pastoral retreat from the city, the Benton Farmhouse is the perfect place for large families and friend groups to reconnect and reflect with the people who mean the most to you. Spacious, and boasting old-world charm, this beautifully restored historic home radiates an abundance of warmth. Conveniently located on Route 14A in the middle of the Wine region of the Finger Lakes, this home is perfectly located to tour and explore the area. It can also serve as a relaxing base for wedding parties using multiple local wedding venues.
Enjoy cozy movie viewings from the comfort of the spacious living room's soft seating. Engage in some playful competition over a game of chess under the glow of the library's lamps, or any of the many games for all ages in the living room or the huge recreation room. When hunger arises, head for the well-equipped kitchen and play chef amongst the full suite of appliances and ample meal prep space. Serving your dishes will be a breeze at the expansive, formal dining table. After eating, enjoy a night in while playing Ping-Pong in the wood-lined recreation room/TV-watching area. Mix your game nights with delicious concoctions prepared at the recreation room bar.
With six large bedrooms to choose from, rest assured that no one's comfort will go unattended to. Each of the rooms offers soft linens, vintage decor pieces and furniture, and cool air - thanks to the home's partial air-conditioning. Additional interior perks include a private washer/dryer, a high chair, internet access, and office space with a desk and printer in the quiet library. After a couple of front door steps, the lower level of the house has a bathroom and bed available.
Outside, enjoy the country breeze while grilling or sitting in front of the dancing flames in the fire pit. Enormous lawns encourage spirited games of corn hole and badminton, while the large driveway can be set up for pickleball, all of which are supplied.
When exploring the surrounding area, be sure to check out the numerous regional wineries, excellent local restaurants (we can suggest our favorites), charming Penn Yan (“Penn' for the Pennsylvanians and “Yan” for the Yankees who settled the area in the early 1800s), the scenic Finger Lakes, Keuka Lake Outlet trail, Keuka Lake State Park, Finger Lakes Rail Riders (just around the corner), Canandaigua Country Club, or further up the road, Hunt Hollow Ski Club. Don't be surprised if you encounter horse-drawn buggies sharing local roads on your way to Windmill Market just south of Penn Yan, which hosts dozens of shops, produce, and food to enjoy.
House Rules
Check-in time: 4:00 PM
Check-out time: 10:00 AM
All guests shall abide by the good neighbor policy and shall not engage in illegal activity. Quiet hours are from 10:00 PM to 8:00 AM
No smoking is permitted anywhere on the premises.
Amenities
Non-smoking
No pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Finger Lakes, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2026
Our family group of 11 was very comfortable here as this house has lots of room to spread out and a well-stocked kitchen with plenty of dishes. The backyard was great for playing frisbee and roasting s-mores.
8 / 10Excellent·Apr 2026
The house was lovely, vintage, and clean. The beds were comfortable and the kitchen well supplied. However, I had been told there was a bedroom on the first floor which there was not. Also it took a bit to figure out the many thermostats and that the radiators were actually turned off in two of the bedrooms.For whatever reason there was an invasion of stink bugs and we disposed of no less than 30-40 of them. We were also disappointed that there were workers there when we arrived repairing the front steps so that we had to carry luggage through the grass to enter the back door. Also the landscapers were there bright and early Sunday morning with all their equipment.We made the best of the situations and as always had a good time. Minus the issues we had, the house is great.
8 / 10Excellent·Oct 2025
House was huge and had plenty of room for a big group. It had a nice outdoor space and the room with the bar and ping pong table was great. The house was clean and stocked with soaps, toilet paper, and paper towels. There were plenty of yard games to choose from as well. TVs were large and equipped with Roku. The biggest dissapointment was the kitchen. It was small and many of the appliances were quite old. The dishwasher barely worked. We also had a hard time finding equipment we needed. There was only 1 frying pan, for example, and they didn't have a complete set of steak knives. The property manager definitely needs to inventory, organize, and restock the kitchen.Other than that, the house was really an amazing property. It was great for anyone who wants to be in the Finger Lakes but doesn't need to be on the water.The house is managed by Vacasa. I found them to be inconsistent with communication. Some messages were answered quickly, and others took days. Also, be aware that this house does not have an option for early check-in, so I would avoid if that's important to you. They did have a late checkout option, although we did not take advantage of it.Overall, a good option for large groups looking for a weekend getaway.
6 / 10Average·Jul 2025
Limited parking but otherwise spacious property. Large bedrooms, many doors stick, and one bathroom the door can't be closed all the way. Window AC units worked well, but one bedroom does not have an air conditioner and was very warm. The first night there (July 4) we were eating in the dining room and heard a loud "bang" and the floor shook. I texted for help and they eventually agreed to have maintenance investigate. The metal support post in the basement had corroded and collapsed making the dinning room floor very "spongey". We were told not to use the dining room until repairs could be made. They were made the next day and I've been waiting ever since to hear about any compensation for loss of the dining room. I never heard from the owner.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9Outstanding
(22 Ratings)
"Our family group of 11 was very comfortable here as this house has lots of room to spread out and a well-stocked kitchen with plenty of dishes. The backyard was great for playing frisbee and roasting..."
Carol M.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
