House in Lake Placid, NY
10 guests · 6 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
About this house rental
License Number: 2026-STR-0477 The home (1908) is a historic Lake Placid guest house originally built to welcome visitors arriving in the Adirondacks during the early days of mountain tourism.
This house is a historic Lake Placid residence, carefully preserved for guests who value authenticity, craftsmanship, and homes with a sense of permanence. This is not a modern hotel experience. It is best suited for those who appreciate patina, history, and refined imperfection.
Important note:
To preserve the integrity of the home and maintain a peaceful village setting, occupancy is limited to 10 registered guests. Parties, events, and additional visitors are not permitted.
License Number: 2026-STR-0477
⸻
Set just 200 yards from Mirror Lake and moments from Main Street, The Huttlinger House offers a rare opportunity to stay in one of Lake Placid’s enduring historic homes—where village life, mountain views, and Olympic legacy quietly converge.
Constructed in 1908 by local builders Carl Miller and Ferd Wilkins, the home spans more than 3,000 square feet and reflects the craftsmanship of its era. Original maple hardwood floors, finely detailed doors and ceilings, and a commanding stone fireplace define the house’s timeless interior.
Multiple porches—both enclosed and open—invite you to take in elevated views of Mirror Lake, the surrounding mountains, and the village below. Throughout the day, natural light moves gracefully through the house, reinforcing a sense of calm and connection to place.
⸻
The Main Level
The first floor unfolds with quiet intention:
• A gracious original entry hall with period wallpaper and wood paneling
• A refined library sitting room with sliding doors and pull-out sofa
• A classic Adirondack living room anchored by the original stone fireplace (decorative only)
• A sunroom offering panoramic village and lake views
• A formal dining room, full bath, and thoughtfully appointed kitchen
⸻
The Second Floor
The second floor features four well-proportioned bedrooms:
• Two queen bedrooms
• Two king bedrooms, including one with a traditional sleeping porch
• Two full baths (not en-suite, consistent with the home’s historic design)
⸻
The third floor remains preserved and is not accessible to guests.
It has been intentionally left untouched as part of the home’s original structure and in accordance with village safety regulations.
⸻
Basement level is off limits.
⸻
A House With History
The property sits on land dating back to post–Revolutionary War grants, later owned by Gerrit Smith, the noted abolitionist and reformer.
Over time the home became known as the Cautin House, later serving as a refined guest house before becoming the long-held residence of the Huttlinger family. The home welcomed an eclectic circle of visitors, including Sports Illustrated photographers during the 1980 Winter Olympics.
For more than six decades the house was a setting for seasonal traditions, intimate gatherings, and the quiet rhythms of village life.
Today, it is offered once again—not as a transient stay, but as a considered Lake Placid experience.
⸻
Whether your visit centers on skiing Whiteface Mountain, paddling on Mirror Lake, or simply enjoying the understated pleasures of the village, The Huttlinger House offers a level of character, history, and presence rarely found today.
High Peaks: The tallest mountain in New York State, Mount Marcy, is located just outside the village, according to Matador Network.
This house is a historic Lake Placid residence, carefully preserved for guests who value authenticity, craftsmanship, and homes with a sense of permanence. This is not a modern hotel experience. It is best suited for those who appreciate patina, history, and refined imperfection.
Important note:
To preserve the integrity of the home and maintain a peaceful village setting, occupancy is limited to 10 registered guests. Parties, events, and additional visitors are not permitted.
License Number: 2026-STR-0477
⸻
Set just 200 yards from Mirror Lake and moments from Main Street, The Huttlinger House offers a rare opportunity to stay in one of Lake Placid’s enduring historic homes—where village life, mountain views, and Olympic legacy quietly converge.
Constructed in 1908 by local builders Carl Miller and Ferd Wilkins, the home spans more than 3,000 square feet and reflects the craftsmanship of its era. Original maple hardwood floors, finely detailed doors and ceilings, and a commanding stone fireplace define the house’s timeless interior.
Multiple porches—both enclosed and open—invite you to take in elevated views of Mirror Lake, the surrounding mountains, and the village below. Throughout the day, natural light moves gracefully through the house, reinforcing a sense of calm and connection to place.
⸻
The Main Level
The first floor unfolds with quiet intention:
• A gracious original entry hall with period wallpaper and wood paneling
• A refined library sitting room with sliding doors and pull-out sofa
• A classic Adirondack living room anchored by the original stone fireplace (decorative only)
• A sunroom offering panoramic village and lake views
• A formal dining room, full bath, and thoughtfully appointed kitchen
⸻
The Second Floor
The second floor features four well-proportioned bedrooms:
• Two queen bedrooms
• Two king bedrooms, including one with a traditional sleeping porch
• Two full baths (not en-suite, consistent with the home’s historic design)
⸻
The third floor remains preserved and is not accessible to guests.
It has been intentionally left untouched as part of the home’s original structure and in accordance with village safety regulations.
⸻
Basement level is off limits.
⸻
A House With History
The property sits on land dating back to post–Revolutionary War grants, later owned by Gerrit Smith, the noted abolitionist and reformer.
Over time the home became known as the Cautin House, later serving as a refined guest house before becoming the long-held residence of the Huttlinger family. The home welcomed an eclectic circle of visitors, including Sports Illustrated photographers during the 1980 Winter Olympics.
For more than six decades the house was a setting for seasonal traditions, intimate gatherings, and the quiet rhythms of village life.
Today, it is offered once again—not as a transient stay, but as a considered Lake Placid experience.
⸻
Whether your visit centers on skiing Whiteface Mountain, paddling on Mirror Lake, or simply enjoying the understated pleasures of the village, The Huttlinger House offers a level of character, history, and presence rarely found today.
High Peaks: The tallest mountain in New York State, Mount Marcy, is located just outside the village, according to Matador Network.
Amenities
Free Parking
Air conditioning
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
TV
Heating
Refrigerator
Kitchen
WiFi/Internet
Parking Available
Microwave
Dishwasher
Washing machine
Dryer
Washer/dryer
Patio
Kitchenware
Garden
Kettle
Oven
Stove
Laundry services
Bath or shower
Outdoor Cooking
Ironing facilities
Towels
Linens
Dining table
Hairdryer
Fire extinguisher
Map of Lake Placid, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2026
First and foremost, John and Ashley, our hosts, are wonderful people. They are so passionate about their property and provided a great experience. I had a couple of calls with John where you can definitely tell that he loves the property and the Lake Placid. My friend arrived in Lake Placid earlier than the check-in time and Ashley was able to check him in a little early which was great for him. Ashley was in contact through our 3 night stay and shipped a couple of shirts that my friend left behind. There is no question that John and Ashley are hosts that you want to work with.The property is historic and quite large. It took us a couple of walk throughs to get acquainted with the layout. While the interior was spacious, we felt quite cozy inside. My friend took pictures and when he showed the pics to his wife, she started to look at flights so that she can stay. That says alot! The interior reflects what you want when you visit Lake Placid. A place with an interior which reflects over 100 years of history. Partial view of Mirror Lake, enough to see swimmers and paddle boarders, with the cloud filled mountains behind it. It was raining most of the time when we were there and we did not get to make use of the yard with fire pit. We did use the new Weber gas grill. The stairs are winders, so you need to pay attention to where you step. The bedrooms are large and the comforters are great!We already decided that we will come back to this property next year, if available.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.4Outstanding
(4 Ratings)
"First and foremost, John and Ashley, our hosts, are wonderful people. They are so passionate about their property and provided a great experience. I had a couple of calls with John where you can defin..."
Howard S.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
