Cottage in Spider Lake, WI
6 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
High-end valueWell priced for this area
Book with confidenceWe partner with the top travel sites so you know you're getting a great deal on the perfect rental
About this cottage rental
Butler’s Bay Cottage on Teal Lake is a newly remodeled vacation rental located on the shores of one of the Hayward, Wisconsin area’s most popular Quiet Lakes, offering a peaceful and relaxing Northwoods getaway.
This cozy cottage features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, making it ideal for couples, small families, or a quiet retreat with friends. One bedroom includes a queen-size bed, while the second bedroom offers two twin beds. A sofa sleeper provides additional sleeping space.
Step outside and enjoy beautiful lake views just steps from the water—perfect for morning coffee, lakeside picnics, or swimming along the shoreline. Guests are welcome to bring their boat and use the private dock, or simply relax and take in the serene surroundings.
Outdoor amenities include a grill, fire pit with lawn chairs, and a picnic table, creating the perfect space for evenings by the lake. Inside, the cottage offers two comfortable sitting areas, a dining room, and a new washer and dryer. Recent updates include central air conditioning, ensuring a comfortable stay during warm summer days.
For larger groups, Butler’s Bay Cabin next door can be added to your reservation for additional space.
Teal Lake is well known for its excellent fishing and connects to Lost Land Lake, offering even more opportunities to explore the water. As a designated Quiet Lake with a 10-mph speed limit, it’s ideal for enjoying a pontoon ride or exploring by kayak or paddleboard, which are available to rent during your stay.
Please note: Parking is limited.
Whether you’re looking to unplug, fish, swim, or simply enjoy the peaceful beauty of Northern Wisconsin, Butler’s Bay Cottage is the perfect lakeside escape.
This cozy cottage features 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, making it ideal for couples, small families, or a quiet retreat with friends. One bedroom includes a queen-size bed, while the second bedroom offers two twin beds. A sofa sleeper provides additional sleeping space.
Step outside and enjoy beautiful lake views just steps from the water—perfect for morning coffee, lakeside picnics, or swimming along the shoreline. Guests are welcome to bring their boat and use the private dock, or simply relax and take in the serene surroundings.
Outdoor amenities include a grill, fire pit with lawn chairs, and a picnic table, creating the perfect space for evenings by the lake. Inside, the cottage offers two comfortable sitting areas, a dining room, and a new washer and dryer. Recent updates include central air conditioning, ensuring a comfortable stay during warm summer days.
For larger groups, Butler’s Bay Cabin next door can be added to your reservation for additional space.
Teal Lake is well known for its excellent fishing and connects to Lost Land Lake, offering even more opportunities to explore the water. As a designated Quiet Lake with a 10-mph speed limit, it’s ideal for enjoying a pontoon ride or exploring by kayak or paddleboard, which are available to rent during your stay.
Please note: Parking is limited.
Whether you’re looking to unplug, fish, swim, or simply enjoy the peaceful beauty of Northern Wisconsin, Butler’s Bay Cottage is the perfect lakeside escape.
Amenities
Air conditioning
Non-smoking
TV
Heating
Coffee/tea maker
Refrigerator
Kitchen
WiFi/Internet
Microwave
Dishwasher
Washing machine
Dryer
Washer/dryer
Kitchenware
No pets allowed
Oven
Stove
Laundry services
Fireplace
Waterfront
Bath or shower
Outdoor Cooking
Sofa bed
Family friendly
Dining table
Desk
Hairdryer
Fire extinguisher
Map of Spider Lake, WI
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2026
Awesome property. Right on Teal Lake. Great fishing and swimming. Very clean and cozy. Will book again.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2026
Rating Details:
The property manager was very helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was very happy with the location.
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
My husband is 3rd generation being on Teal Lake. This was our 1st experience at this cottage. It really felt like home away from home. The pics and description were accurate but somehow still didn't do it justice :) It was a beautiful place! Liz & Kari were wonderful to work with getting the reservations set up. We brought our 11yr old grandson & he enjoyed it all. We use this vacation to fish & enjoy the surroundings.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
We really enjoyed our stay and were very comfortable.
6 / 10Average·Sep 2025
Rating Details:
The property manager was adequately helpful.
The vacation rental was spotless.
I was somewhat unhappy with the location.
I was more than satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental.
Overall, I do not recommend this vacation rental.
Reviewer Comments:
Cabin was good and very clean but....if you are trailering a medium to large boat the parking is poor. Just a heads up.
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.4Outstanding
(18 Ratings)
"Awesome property. Right on Teal Lake. Great fishing and swimming. Very clean and cozy. Will book again."
WilliamDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
