House in Sag Harbor, NY
8 guests · 4 bedrooms · 3 baths
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Top-tier experienceA high end property in this area
About this house rental
Quiet village street bordering over 1,000 acres of greenbelt hiking trails and ponds. This traditional cape is the perfect family getaway, complete with a fabulous yard with fire pit overlooking the park. The backyard is private with plenty of room for outdoor enjoyment. Gorgeous stone terrace with grill and fridge, poolside, is perfect for entertaining. The park is a short walk from our backyard. Month of September special upon request!
Master bedroom on main floor with a new master bath with double rainhead steam shower. Off the bedroom is a small deck and new gunite hot tub.
Great kitchen with stainless steel appliances and sky lights. Screened porch is great for dining while overlooking the beautiful gardens and Gunite pool.
Master bedroom on main floor with a new master bath with double rainhead steam shower. Off the bedroom is a small deck and new gunite hot tub.
Great kitchen with stainless steel appliances and sky lights. Screened porch is great for dining while overlooking the beautiful gardens and Gunite pool.
Amenities
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of Sag Harbor, NY
Ratings and reviews
10 / 10Outstanding·Jul 2026
We have rented many homes over the past 20 years in the Hamptons, and this has been one of the best: 1) Everything works! The heated pool, which actually gets to the temp kids like, the electric pool cover, the hot tub, the AC, the kitchen appliances, the wifi, the fire pit, and even the garbage cans for the twice a week pick up work because they are large and clean.2) The pool is large, and the backyard ample.3) The property is at the end of a dead end cul de sac and abuts a large park, so it is quiet. But there are neighbors so you get the peacefulness of the country without feeling remote.4) The downtown Main Street of Sag Harbor is genuinely walkable, so, as a parent, you spend less time as a chauffeur. And it is a lovely walk passing by Otter pond.5) Our dog was welcome.6) Clean without being fussy. 7) Vine covered pergola with grilling and eating areas. 8) The yard and house are larger than the photos show.9) If you are a Beatles fan, you will enjoy the pictures and books about them.10) Great for a family.The owners have a lovely place and maintain it superbly.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
Our experience here was above and beyond most vacation rentals. Great location in a comfortable family home with room to spread out.
10 / 10Outstanding·Aug 2025
Beautiful property and home! The location was perfect- close to downtown shopping and to Montauk. The pool and hot tub were amazing and it truly had every amenity we could have wanted! The host was super responsive and took care of any questions we had promptly and very much to our satisfaction.
5 / 10·Sep 2020
As beautiful as the photos are for this home on VRBO, they don't convey how exquisite it truly is! The gorgeous back garden has a very English feel, with stone walls, lovely landscaping, and multiple places to relax: on the side deck, just off the master BR, in the Gunite hot tub; poolside, under the pergola; near the fire pit; and on the grassy lawn. We didn't use the grill, but that's there too. The flowers, the trees, the heated Gunite pool—it's all a dream. This place is a true refuge, very peaceful and private. We loved swimming and spending time outside.The house feels welcoming the moment you walk in. Not only because the owners left us lovely flowers and wine(!), but the vibe of the home just seems friendly and warm. It is quite a huge house, but at the same time, it feels cozy. There are several sunny spots to curl up with a great book, have a nap, play a board game, etc. Although this home is "high-end," in terms of the technology, lighting, appliances, marble master bathroom, etc., it's also unfussy and relaxed. The big kitchen is well stocked, so you can do lots of cooking. You'll have everything you need. And you can enjoy your meals in the dining room, the screened-in porch, or right by the pool.Not only was everything exactly as represented online, but....it was even better! Especially because of the pandemic, we were grateful to be here and found it calming and restorative. And since the house is on a cul de sac, it's extra quiet. You'll enjoy taking strolls down the street in the early morning or in the evenings. You can play tennis or do yoga in the nearby park, and the village Main Street is a five-minute drive away. Great shops, restaurants (including Sen, Dockside Grill, and LT Burger), and cafes.Could the owners have done anything else to make our stay better? No! Would we stay here again? Yes, the moment they would have us back.Thanks again for everything!
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.9Outstanding
(47 Ratings)
"We have rented many homes over the past 20 years in the Hamptons, and this has been one of the best: 1) Everything works! The heated pool, which actually gets to the temp kids like, the electric pool..."
John T.Don't miss out! Price and availability may change
