Cottage in New Buffalo, MI
5 guests · 2 bedrooms · 1 bath
Reasons to book
Guests love it hereGuests give this property a top rating
Great for petsBring all your friends and family, even the furry ones
Well priced for this locationPriced under area average
About this cottage rental
Take a deep breath. Warm beach days are yours at the STORYBOOK COTTAGE in New Buffalo, Michigan--the heart of Harbor Country. Just across the lake from Chicago, special times await. Why not spontaneously plan a quick getaway for you & those you love? Whisk your family or special someone away for a time of adventure or relaxation & add another unforgettable chapter to YOUR story! Seize the days &, whatever you do, make them memorable!
Beautiful, idyllic, year-round two-BR bungalow perfect for ROMANCE or SMALL FAMILY BEACH DAYS.. Short walk to main street shopping, restaurants & beach. No need to pack more than your swimsuit & personal care items. Fully stocked kitchen plus more! Large, Breezy Front Porch, Central A/C, Outdoor Fire Pit, W/D, Flat Screen TV/DVD, WiFi, Netflix/Hulu/Disney+, Gas Grill, Picnic Table, Loaner Bikes. Comfortably sleeps 4-5.
From the glistening white sands of Lake Michigan's shores to the lush, beautiful country-side, Harbor Country combines the best of both worlds. Rustic country charm coupled with highly sophisticated shops, restaurants & galleries. And the Storybook Cottage--it's the perfect place to return after a busy day out exploring all that New Buffalo & the surrounding Harbor Country has to offer!
While you are here, we invite you to be our guest and REST, REFRESH, and RECONNECT with those you love. In addition to the sun & sand you've come to expect from the quaint one-stoplight town of New Buffalo, enjoy morning coffee on the porch, concerts in the park, fine & casual dining, antique shops, golf, theaters, vintage markets, farmers markets, art galleries, museums, state parks, nature trails, bike routes, boating, country fairs, festivals, day trips via train to the Windy City, Four Winds Casino, Michigan orchards, vineyards, wineries, & --most importantly--TIME to connect with those you love!
When it's time to hunker down for the night, come back "home" to the Storybook Cottage. Rest your head & awake--refreshed--in a place where dreams really do come true.
Beautiful, idyllic, year-round two-BR bungalow perfect for ROMANCE or SMALL FAMILY BEACH DAYS.. Short walk to main street shopping, restaurants & beach. No need to pack more than your swimsuit & personal care items. Fully stocked kitchen plus more! Large, Breezy Front Porch, Central A/C, Outdoor Fire Pit, W/D, Flat Screen TV/DVD, WiFi, Netflix/Hulu/Disney+, Gas Grill, Picnic Table, Loaner Bikes. Comfortably sleeps 4-5.
From the glistening white sands of Lake Michigan's shores to the lush, beautiful country-side, Harbor Country combines the best of both worlds. Rustic country charm coupled with highly sophisticated shops, restaurants & galleries. And the Storybook Cottage--it's the perfect place to return after a busy day out exploring all that New Buffalo & the surrounding Harbor Country has to offer!
While you are here, we invite you to be our guest and REST, REFRESH, and RECONNECT with those you love. In addition to the sun & sand you've come to expect from the quaint one-stoplight town of New Buffalo, enjoy morning coffee on the porch, concerts in the park, fine & casual dining, antique shops, golf, theaters, vintage markets, farmers markets, art galleries, museums, state parks, nature trails, bike routes, boating, country fairs, festivals, day trips via train to the Windy City, Four Winds Casino, Michigan orchards, vineyards, wineries, & --most importantly--TIME to connect with those you love!
When it's time to hunker down for the night, come back "home" to the Storybook Cottage. Rest your head & awake--refreshed--in a place where dreams really do come true.
Amenities
Non-smoking
Pets allowed
Family friendly
Map of New Buffalo, MI
Ratings and reviews
Summary of reviewsGuests loved the comfortable and well-equipped cottage, its proximity to downtown, and the helpful hosts. They appreciated the cozy decor and fully stocked kitchen. The porch was a favorite spot for relaxing.
10 / 10Outstanding·Jun 2026
The cottage is beautiful and family friendly with games, toys, and puzzles. Clean rooms with comfortable beds. Great host with excellent communication.
8 / 10Excellent·Jun 2026
Rebecca was such a lovely host! Very fast to communicate & accommodating. We had the best time on our first family vacation with our toddler. The house had loads of board games, some kids toys, and Rebecca set up a pack and play with sheets, had a little functional high chair (no straps but worked great), and attached a little hook on high chair to the main kitchen table. The house was in the perfect location, far enough from town where it was quiet but still close enough that you could walk if you want to. We ended up driving to the beach because we had so much stuff but it was so easy to park & navigate.
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2026
Adorable cottage! Being walking distance from the beach and so many great restaurants was amazing.
10 / 10Outstanding·May 2026
Great little cabin close to every thing in New Buffalo very clean and cozy
$$$$
Top rated by guests
9.5Outstanding
(93 Ratings)
Guests loved the comfortable and well-equipped cottage, its proximity to downtown, and the helpful hosts. They appreciated the cozy decor and fully stocked kitchen. The porch was a favorite spot for relaxing.
From real guest reviews summarized by AIDon't miss out! Price and availability may change
